Murder Mystery

Updated: Jul 26

I was looking around at some former ferry sites along the Red River and saw Thompson's Ferry at Horseshoe Bend in Love County, Oklahoma in a USGS map from 1943. However, on another later map, the road to the ferry site was marked as "Tuck's Ferry Road." Why the name change? The "Thompson Ferry," named after the nearby Thompson Ranch, ran the same ferry as Tuck did; the Tuck Ferry stopped running before 1930. That sounds like a mundane fact... except there's no such thing as humdrum when it comes to Red River Valley history, as you'll read below.


John Tuck ran the ferry at Horseshoe Bend between Love County, Oklahoma and Cooke County, Texas for nearly thirty years. He farmed along the Red River in Cooke County, but traded that occupation for ferrying sometime in the 1890s when he took over the Black & Robertson Ferry in the Chickasaw Nation. For over three decades, John Tuck ferried cattle drovers, covered wagon trains, gunslingers, moonshiners, and automobile tourists over the river.


Tragedy struck in 1925, when John and his son, Cuburt, were killed by a young man named Charles Starrett after Cuburt Tuck befriended a "young but troubled woman" who called herself Mae Tracy. Mae Tracy, which may have not been her real name, had been employed at Joe Tuck's restaurant in Marietta (Love County, Oklahoma) for a short time, but was dismissed by John Tuck, who was helping his son manage the business after the daughter-in-law fell ill. Mae Tracy opened her own restaurant and became friendly with a young soldier, Charles Starrett. One drunken night, Starrett entered Joe Tuck's cafe and started a fight with Cuburt. John Tuck defended his son, then called the Sheriff to remove Starrett. That same evening, Starrett returned and shot John and Cuburt Tuck to death.


That same night, Mae Tracy closed her restaurant and tried to flee Marietta. And that's how the murder of a old-time ferry man became sensationalized throughout the country: what did Mae Tracy know?


But that's not all! In August of 1925, Charles Sterrett petitioned the court to remove Judge W. F. Freeman from the case because he, according to Sterrett's brief, "is a man who... is agreat lover of newspaper publicity" and is prejudiced against Sterrett. The OK Court of Criminal Appeals granted the petition.


I haven't been able to find out anything about the outcome of the murder trial of Charles Starrett's (also spelled Starritt in some accounts). It doesn't help that around the same time, a B-List movie star with the same name starred in a movie called "Jungle Bride," making the search a bit convoluted. I learned that he was sentenced but released later and apparently, married Mae Tracy.


Tuck's ferry is depicted in the St. Louis Post Dispatch as the newspaper explained the murder mystery in 1925.

After Tuck's murder, the ferry landing became known as Thompson's (USGS).


12 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All